| William Carey University | High | Player(s) | Opponent | Date | |
| Total Points | 35 | Drew Meyerchick | vs Dillard University | 02/04/10 | |
| Field Goals Made | 12 | Drew Meyerchick | vs Dillard University | 02/04/10 | |
| Field Goals Attempted | 20 | Brandon Cooks | vs Union University TN | 01/04/10 | |
| Field Goal% (Min 5 made) | 1.000 | (6/6) | Brandon Cooks | vs Blue Mountain College | 11/07/09 |
| 1.000 | (6/6) | Cory Smith | vs Univ of Mobile | 03/04/10 | |
| 1.000 | (6/6) | Cory Smith | vs LSU-Shreveport | 01/16/10 | |
| 3pt Field Goals Made | 8 | Drew Meyerchick | vs Dillard University | 02/04/10 | |
| 3pt Field Goals Attempted | 11 | Drew Meyerchick | vs Dillard University | 02/04/10 | |
| 3pt Field Goal% (Min 2 made) | 1.000 | (3/3) | Brandon Cooks | vs Blue Mountain College | 11/07/09 |
| 1.000 | (3/3) | Drew Meyerchick | vs Wesley | 11/30/09 | |
| 1.000 | (2/2) | Terry Wade | vs Xavier Univ of Louisiana | 02/13/10 | |
| Free Throws Made | 19 | Terry Wade | vs Univ of Mobile | 03/04/10 | |
| Free Throws Attempted | 30 | Terry Wade | vs Univ of Mobile | 03/04/10 | |
| Free Throw% (Min 4 made) | 1.000 | (9/9) | Cory Smith | vs Tougaloo | 01/28/10 |
| 1.000 | (6/6) | Brandon Cooks | vs SUNO | 02/20/10 | |
| 1.000 | (6/6) | Drew Meyerchick | vs Loyola University | 01/30/10 | |
| 1.000 | (6/6) | Marcus Spann | vs Univ of Mobile | 03/04/10 | |
| 1.000 | (6/6) | Marcus Spann | vs Xavier Univ of Louisiana | 02/13/10 | |
| Offensive Rebounds | 8 | Brandon Cooks | vs Univ Saint Thomas TX | 12/17/09 | |
| Defensive Rebounds | 12 | Brandon Cooks | vs Dillard University | 01/14/10 | |
| Total Rebounds | 18 | Brandon Cooks | vs Dillard University | 02/04/10 | |
| Fouls | 6 | Brandon Cooks | vs Blue Mountain College | 11/07/09 | |
| Assists | 9 | Chris Cyprian | vs Belhaven College | 01/09/10 | |
| Turnovers | 7 | Chris Cyprian | vs Xavier Univ of Louisiana | 01/23/10 | |
| 7 | Chris Cyprian | vs LSU-Shreveport | 01/16/10 | ||
| 7 | Anthony Wilcher | vs Union University TN | 01/04/10 | ||
| Blocks | 6 | Brandon Cooks | vs Univ of Mobile | 03/04/10 | |
| 6 | Chris Cyprian | vs Pensacola Christian | 11/28/09 | ||
| Steals | 5 | Drew Meyerchick | vs Pensacola Christian | 11/14/09 | |
| 5 | Drew Meyerchick | vs LSU-Shreveport | 03/06/10 | ||
| 5 | Cory Smith | vs Pensacola Christian | 11/14/09 | ||
| Minutes Played | 56:00 | Marcus Spann | vs Univ of Mobile | 03/04/10 | |
